NYPD cop knelt on teen’s back, fired gun — but is still on force: court docs

Posted on March 7, 2021

An NYPD officer lied for almost a decade about the circumstances of a 2009 Bronx shooting in which he straddled a teenager and fired into his lower back at “point-blank” range, according to newly unearthed court documents.

Read the full story

Monahan to be grilled over NYPD’s ‘aggressive actions’ during George Floyd protests

Posted on Feb. 25, 2021

The NYPD’s outgoing Chief of Department is expected to be grilled next week by the CCRB over police tactics during the George Floyd demonstrations last summer — but the highest-ranking uniformed officer avoided facing his own misconduct complaints after being tapped for a new city gig, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

How the NYPD obtains people’s personal data with no oversight

Posted on Nov. 16, 2020

The NYPD has used tens of thousands of questionable subpoenas over the last decade to intimidate private companies into handing over the personal information of cops and civilians alike — all with no oversight from the city or the courts, The Post has found.

Read the full story

NYPD data: Only about 20 percent of NYC shootings ended in arrests this year

Posted on Sept. 6, 2020

The city is gripped by a gun-violence epidemic, but only about 20 percent of shootings have ended with an arrest, according to a Post analysis of NYPD data through late August.

Read the full story

NYPD uses misleading footage to excuse inaction during teen beatdown

Posted on Aug. 13, 2020

The NYPD used a misleading video in an attempt to defend its own inaction after two-dozen cops were caught standing idly by as a teenage girl was thrashed in the street, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

Data doesn’t support De Blasio, NYPD claim that shooting surge is due to court shutdown

Posted on July 30, 2020

The mayor and police have repeatedly blamed a coronavirus-related court shutdown for the explosion of gun violence rocking the city — but firearms cases are making their way through the criminal justice system at the same rate as last year, a Post investigation shows.

Read the full story

NYPD’s own stats debunk claims of bail reform leading to spike in gun violences

Posted on July 8, 2020

State bail reform and coronavirus-related releases from city jails are not driving this year’s surge in shootings, the NYPD’s own data shows — despite the insistence of department brass to the contrary.

Read the full story

NYPD won’t discipline cops who skip CCRB’s police-brutality video hearings

Posted on July 5, 2020

The city’s police watchdog has asked the NYPD to discipline cops who follow their unions’ advice by skipping misconduct hearings — but the department has refused to get involved, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

How conspiracy theories about the NYPD Shake Shack ‘poisoning’ blew up

Posted on June 22, 2020

The three cops at the center of the NYPD milkshake “poisoning” scandal never even got sick, and there wasn’t the slightest whiff of criminality from the get-go — but that didn’t stop gung-ho brass from rolling out the crime scene tape and unions from dishing out empty conspiracy theories, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea ignores his own ‘misinformation’ warnings

Posted on June 8, 2020

Police Commissioner Dermot Shea has admonished politicians and the public for trafficking in “rumors” while criticizing the NYPD’s response to city unrest — but hasn’t held himself to the same standard, a Post investigation found.

Read the full story

NYPD has hundreds more coronavirus cases than previously reported

Posted on April 15, 2020

The number of NYPD members who have contracted the coronavirus has actually topped 4,000 — far more than what has been publicized, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

Scores of ‘probable’ coronavirus deaths not counted in NYC tally

Posted on Aapril 7, 2020

Dozens — if not hundreds — of coronavirus deaths in New York City will not be included in the Big Apple’s grim tally, because victims died at home without being tested, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

Cops furious over NYPD response as coronavirus pandemic tightens grip on city

Posted on March 18, 2020

The NYPD is trying to reassure its rank-and-file during the coronavirus pandemic that has gripped the Big Apple — but cops feel like the top brass couldn’t care less about their well-being.

Read the full story

De Blasio bills taxpayers for Red Sox tickets as part of his failed 2020 bid

Posted on Feb. 18, 2020

New York City taxpayers picked up the tab for Mayor Bill de Blasio’s security detail to tag along with him to watch his beloved Boston Red Sox play 2,500 miles away in Los Angeles amid his failed presidential bid last year, The Post has found.

Read the full story

Rogue NYPD cops are using facial recognition app Clearview

Posted on Jan. 23, 2020

Rogue NYPD officers are using sketchy facial recognition software on their personal phones that the department’s own facial recognition unit doesn’t want to touch because of concerns about security and potential for abuse, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

NYPD tried to jam up cop who criticized handling of cop-suicide epidemic

Posted on Nov. 10, 2019

The day after a Big Apple cop exclusively told The Post he had been ostracized for seeking mental-health treatment amid an officer-suicide epidemic, the department reached out — but only to jam him up more, he said.

Read the full story

Another batch of ‘bad cops’ made public by Brooklyn DA

Posted on Nov. 6, 2019

The Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office has released a redacted list of “bad cops” who prosecutors may not want to put on the stand — the second DA office to do so.

Read the full story

NYPD response to officer suicides is ‘smoke and mirrors,’ cop says

Posted on Oct. 28, 2019

Amid an epidemic of officer suicides, the NYPD’s recent calls for stressed-out cops to “Please reach out” for help is nothing more than “smoke and mirrors,” according to an officer who said he was publicly stripped of his gun and reassigned the day after revealing he was on antidepressants.

Read the full story

Fired NYPD cop Daniel Pantaleo sues to get his job back

Posted on Oct. 23, 2019

The cop fired over the death of Eric Garner is suing the police commissioner and the NYPD to try and get his job back, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

NYPD fires Officer Daniel Pantaleo in ‘chokehold’ death of Eric Garner

Posted on Aug. 19, 2019

NYPD cop Daniel Panatelo has been fired for causing the death of Eric Garner, Police Commissioner James O’Neill announced Monday.

Read the full story

De Blasio muzzled NYPD, CCRB from testifying on planned repeal of records law

Posted on Oct. 17, 2019

Mayor Bill de Blasio barred officials from the NYPD and the CCRB from testifying Thursday about the planned repeal of a law that shields police personnel files — so they wouldn’t clash in public, The Post has learned.

Read the full story

Bronx DA names 75 NYPD members on ‘naughty list’ for shoddy police work

Posted on Oct. 7, 2019

The Bronx District Attorney’s Office became the first in the city on Monday to publicly release a “naughty list” of NYPD members whose credibility could lead to criminal cases being tossed. The heavily redacted records, obtained by The Post through a Freedom of Information request...

Read the full story

NYPD’s tally of lawsuit settlements fails to account for $22 million

Posted on Sept. 15, 2019

City Hall’s official tally of NYPD lawsuit settlements is woefully incomplete — and fails to account for $22 million in deals struck during the first three months of this year alone, The Post has learned.

>Read the full story

Cop’s $5M settlement didn’t make cut in NYPD misconduct database

Posted on Sept. 15, 2019

A city database meant to shed light on police misconduct settlements is missing the largest deal struck in the first three months of the year — even though it involved cops on both sides.

Read the full story

How NYPD’s facial recognition software ID’ed subway rice cooker kook

Posted on Aug. 25, 2019

NYPD detectives identified the mystery man who sparked terror by leaving a pair of rice cookers in a subway long before their bomb-squad counterparts even realized the devices were harmless — thanks to controversial face-scanning technology.

Read the full story

‘Lying’ cops called to testify at trials: prosecutor’s records

Posted on May 17, 2019

Five NYPD cops found guilty of lying didn’t just keep their jobs — they were set to bear witness at criminal trials as recently as January, The Post has learned. Manhattan District Attorney’s Office papers obtained by the Post detail strikes against at least 31 NYPD members.

Read the full story

For 17 years, N.J. had the chance to stop potentially dangerous cops. The state failed to do it.

Posted on Nov. 29, 2018

Behind every baton blow and broken bone, every compliance hold and gunshot wound, there are piles and piles of paper. Somebody had to be keeping tabs, right?...

Read the full story

N.J.'s new plan to root out misbehaving cops is badly flawed, experts say

Posted on June 16, 2018

The intention was simple, N.J. Attorney General Gurbir Grewal said: Be more proactive, identify problem behavior and intervene before a situation gets out of control. As it turns out, however, that new system has a big blind spot....

Read the full story

The Force Report: Explore the data and read the project's coverage


Craig McCarthy was the lead reporter on "The Force Report," an award winning 16-month investigation by NJ Advance Media.

He filed hundreds of public record requests and coordinated data collection and input while co-leading the reporting effort.


In Edison, a police force under investigation braces for more arrests

Posted on Aug. 28, 2018

Mayor Daniel Reiman attended a golf fundraiser hosted by a non-profit aimed at supporting "unfairly" charged officers, which was formed a week after his brother, a Carteret cop, was arrested...

Read the full story

An embattled police force facing 5 lawsuits. Hear why officers are suing.

Posted on June 16, 2018

It all started with the unexpected massage of her shoulders followed by an unwelcome kiss on her neck, she said. Sgt. Kia Brooks hurried out of the elevator and away from one of her supervisors...

Read the full story

'Can I buy that flamethrower?' and other burning questions I had at my first gun show

Posted on June 16, 2018

In the back of the Allstar Family Fun & Events Complex in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, past the skeeball tables and arcade games, dozens of dealers are set up in the 48,000-square-foot space, and all...

Read the full story

Teen accuses town cops of punching, kicking him after crash

Posted on June 7, 2017

The Middlesex County Prosecutor's Office is investigating allegations that police officers punched, kicked and bloodied a 16-year-old suspect...

Read the full story

In Carteret, indicted cop accounted for fifth of arrests involving force

Posted on Oct 10, 2017

The borough police officer charged with assaulting a teenager is responsible for more than one-fifth of all arrests involving force recorded by the department...

Read the full story

Did racist 'Make Edison Great Again' election mailer break any laws?

Posted on Nov. 2, 2017

Authorities are looking into whether the "Make Edison Great Again" anti-Indian and anti-Chinese school board election mailers sent to township residents violated any campaign regulations or criminal laws...

Read the full story

Charity for 'unfairly' charged police pops up week after mayor's cop brother is arrested

Posted on Oct. 24, 2017

Mayor Daniel Reiman attended a golf fundraiser hosted by a non-profit aimed at supporting "unfairly" charged officers, which was formed a week after his brother, a Carteret cop, was arrested...

Read the full story

Ex-cop's 'nightmarish storyline' deserves 20 years in prison, judge says

Posted on Sept. 7, 2017

Michael Dotro, the former Edison cop who orchestrated a series retaliation plots against those who crossed him, including other officers, was sentenced to 20 years in prison for firebombing his supervisor's home...

Read the full story

Jury to decide fate of accused mastermind in pickaxe killing

Posted on June 16, 2017

Without the influence of a Woodbridge man, the 28-year-old Edison man brutally killed with pickaxe would still be alive today, prosecutors said...

Read the full story

'Unprecedented' vote by borough council on police hiring raises nepotism questions

Posted on May 21, 2017

Two borough councilwomen refused to recuse themselves from voting recently to approve the hiring of five new police officers from a pool of candidates that includes their relatives...

Read the full story

Watch famed 'Perfect Storm' rescue ship sink off N.J. coast

Posted on May 10, 2017

A famed Coast Guard cutter and former Navy tug has entered its third tour of duty as it now sits 135 feet below sea level off the coast of New Jersey...

Read the full story

'My father died in our arms:' Read girl's plea for dad's killer to get life

Posted on May 09, 2017

Ania, now 11-years-old, wrote an emotional letter to the judge before the sentencing Monday of her father's killer Roland Amos, detailing the night her father died ...

Read the full story

Where are the media while Trump is at his Bedminster golf club?

Posted on May 6, 2017

As Donald Trump christens his Bedminster golf course with his first weekend visit as president, the national press pool is spending the time working in a hotel...

Read the full story

Strangers help N.J. woman finish Boston Marathon after she collapsed

Posted on April 19, 2017

Julianne Bowe returned to the Boston Marathon this year determined to overcome the 26.2-mile challenge after having to withdraw the previous year mid-race...

Read the full story

N.J. police departments to face new rules for military surplus requests

Posted on April 3, 2017

The state Attorney General's Office will overhaul its rules for how local police departments can obtain military equipment such as heavily armored vehicles...

Read the full story

N.J. cops' 2-year military surplus haul: $40M in gear, 13 armored vehicles

Posted on February 20, 2017

Police departments across New Jersey received thousands of military hand-me-downs -- including 13 heavily-armored vehicles -- over the past two years...

Read the full story

Senseless stabbing deaths of young siblings test community's faith

Posted on November 30, 2016

"It makes no sense," Rev. Edward Allen said to a crowd of close to 200 family, friends and community members Wednesday morning at New Hope Baptist Church...

Read the full story

New video shows NJ Transit driver ran red light in fatal Newark bus crash

Posted on October 14, 2016

"It makes no sense," Rev. Edward Allen said to a crowd of close to 200 family, friends and community members Wednesday morning at New Hope Baptist Church...

Read the full story

'I thought they were decorated candles' - Homeless man recounts life-saving bomb find

Posted on September 30, 2016

Lee Parker thought he was just lucky Sunday when he stumbled upon a nice backpack left on top of a garbage can, steps from the Elizabeth train station...

Read the full story

Woman killed in NJ Transit bus crash had walked to work before home burned down

Posted on August 21, 2016

Irma Garcia said she had a "feeling in her stomach" about her 49-year-old mother, Jesy, after she woke up Friday and saw the news of a fatal NJ Transit bus crash in downtown Newark...

Read the full story

Witnesses describe 'total chaos' after fatal NJ Transit bus crash in Newark

Posted on August 19, 2016

The Newark intersection where two NJ Transit buses collided early Friday transformed into "total chaos" as people rushed to pull the injured from the twisted wreckage, witnesses said...

Read the full story

N.J. continues to lead in foreclosures as country rebounds

Posted on July 25, 2016

New Jersey continues to lead the country in foreclosures despite a national trend showing many states recovering to pre-recession numbers...

Read the full story

How a startling number of fatal N.J. crashes involve unlicensed drivers, and why it's hard to stop them

Posted on May 10, 2015

One out of every 10 fatal accidents that occurred between 2010 and 2013 in New Jersey involved a driver without a valid license, accounting for more than 200 deaths, according to data...

Read the full story

Craig McCarthy

Social Contact

Copyright (c) CraigMcCarthy.Press
All rights reserved.